Greece

Paradoxes

Motion and plurality lead to logical contradictions when analyzed carefully, which defends Parmenides's claim that reality is a single, unchanging whole by showing that the common-sense alternative is actually incoherent.

Zeno of Elea, a student and defender of Parmenides, is known through Aristotle's Physics and later commentators for a set of paradoxes designed to show that motion and plurality generate contradictions, defending his teacher's monism by attacking its rivals rather than by adding new positive doctrine. The most famous, Achilles and the tortoise, argues that a faster runner can never overtake a slower one given a head start, since he must first reach the point where the tortoise started, by which time it has moved further ahead, in an infinite regress; the Dichotomy paradox similarly shows that any motion requires completing infinitely many sub-motions first. Aristotle called Zeno the inventor of dialectic, and his paradoxes remained a genuine mathematical and philosophical puzzle, addressed by thinkers from Aristotle through the development of calculus limits, for over two thousand years.

Read the text

Descends from

Fed into

Commentary

Readers' notes on this work. No account needed - be scholarly, or at least civil.

Loading commentary…