Greece

Apology

Apologia Sokratous

An examined life lived in pursuit of truth is worth more than an unexamined one bought with survival, and Socrates would rather be condemned to death than stop questioning his fellow citizens.

The Apology presents Plato's account of the speech Socrates gave in his own defense at his trial in 399 BC on charges of impiety and corrupting the youth of Athens. Rather than begging for mercy in the conventional manner, Socrates uses the trial as an occasion to explain and defend the whole practice of his life: a divine mission, he claims, prompted by the Delphic oracle's declaration that no one was wiser than he, which he tested by cross-examining politicians, poets, and craftsmen only to find that their apparent wisdom did not survive scrutiny. His own wisdom, he concludes, consists in knowing that he does not know, a stance later tradition calls Socratic ignorance (the phrase 'Socratic paradox' is a modern label properly reserved for his separate claims that virtue is knowledge and that no one does wrong willingly), and which he presents as the reason powerful Athenians came to resent and eventually prosecute him.

Socrates refuses every conventional move that might have saved his life. He declines to bring his weeping family before the jury for sympathy, calling such displays theatrical and unworthy of a serious man, and after the jury convicts him he proposes as his own counter-penalty, against his accusers' demand for death, not exile or a fine but free meals at public expense, a proposal that reads as sincere insistence on his own civic value even as it provokes more jurors to vote for his execution than had voted to convict him in the first place. His famous claim that the unexamined life is not worth living for a human being crystallizes the speech's central argument: that philosophical self-examination is not a luxury or an eccentricity but the necessary work of a human life, and that a city which kills the man performing that work for it does itself the greater injury.

The Apology functions as both historical testimony, however shaped by Plato's own philosophical purposes, and as a founding document of Western philosophy's self-image: the philosopher as gadfly, stinging a complacent state into self-awareness at personal cost. Its closing meditation, that death is either a dreamless sleep or a migration to converse with the wise dead, and therefore nothing to fear, set the terms for how philosophy would treat mortality for centuries after.

Read the text

Fed into

Commentary

Readers' notes on this work. No account needed - be scholarly, or at least civil.

Loading commentary…